Comments with a thumbs up, by Madster

HOME » PST members » Madster » Thumbs-up comments

Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Is this a portrait of Heather Mills? Cute chop. Very creative, but the shadow is too light, and extends too far around the leg. It would be much closer and darker, being on the ground.

(239 days ago)


AHHHH Bugger.
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Wild concept. Could have used some sort of background, though.

(239 days ago)


spider woman
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The light source of the background is entirely missing from the base, and opposite the highlights on the legs of the creature Great imagination, tho.

(239 days ago)


Don't walk in the woods
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Excellent chop! The fan looks like it's truly part of the photo. High Vote, you've earned it!

(239 days ago)


Car Airconditioning
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Lovely chop! Great job with the translucent blades!

(240 days ago)


merry go round
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Not enough of the source image visible, it's just a tiny part. Also, the colors need work, the saturation levels are uneven.

(240 days ago)


Departure
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster No source URL - Low Vote, Red Flag.

(244 days ago)


Stained Glass
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The sky should look more overcast , and the green just doesn't work well with the concept.

(244 days ago)


Lightning
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Looks great, but the paint jobs should both match, either both new, or both old...The bottom (old) has more blue tones and faded (desaturated) areas.

(244 days ago)


Tank
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Great, original concept, but the lamp should be emitting light w/corresponding shadows. Shadows was a category you disallowed...No Source URL, Low Vote, Red Flag

(244 days ago)


Kettamp
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Beautiful detail, but the perspective is off for the stage. Jamming all the drums on the bottom also looks weird from a perspective angle. The light reflections on the high hat is off, but a good chop, nonetheless!

(244 days ago)


Kinetic Energy ;)
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Thanks are good, but you need to provide links to the images you use. Read the Guidelines...Great concept, but the drop shadow behind the large woman looks hokey, and detracts from the overall effect.

(249 days ago)


sweet!!
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Very funny! Needs a background horizon to be more believable, and your lighting on the painted cape is wonky, not matching the lighting on the "helmet." Did you paint the arm, or is is a photo?

(249 days ago)


Darth Vadle
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The link for your camera source is not working, you have no shadow for the strong light source, and the overall image is too blurry, but good concept.

(249 days ago)


biz card_47ec25fc50582
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster David Cross's image is copyright. You need a release to use it here.

(249 days ago)


Tobias's biz card
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster No source image citing.

(251 days ago)


Child with a vision
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Good concept, execution is a bit lacking. You can't sneeze with your mouth closed, unless your cheeks puff out from the force. Especially if the sneeze can blow out the lense on his shades...

(251 days ago)


The sneeZe
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Great concept, the execution needs work. The two suns, light blue center line, and blue scribble to the right of center bring the quality noticeably down.

(251 days ago)


cinema
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The sideways flames on the wheels don't match the rest of the image. They should be going upwards like the rest. Heat rises.

(252 days ago)


fire storm
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The lighting is inconsistent with the background, and the blurry wheel at the bottom does not fit the rest of the image. It's too hard to read your background source embedding. Include it with your entry info to reduce confusion.

(252 days ago)


They visited long ago
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster You lost too much of the sunglasses, but a very funny chop!

(252 days ago)


Mr. Potato Head
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The profile shows no real strong lighting from the front, the nose is too light, and the light outline looks out of place

(252 days ago)


photoShot!
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster You can't tell this egg is from the source image. It looks too flat. A stand would help, too.

(252 days ago)


Faberge egg
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The harsh black outlineon the egg, combined with the glow around the edges distracts from the rest of the image. "Eggcellent" job on inserting the girl into the egg!

(252 days ago)


Happy Easter
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The two halves of the egg shell are "eggactly" the same, and the drop shadow is on the opposite side of the light source, but the concept is great!

(252 days ago)


Tye-Dye Breakfast
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The opening for the chick's head needs some work, the head looks too pasted on, and your lighting is too inconsistent with onlyl some of the eggs being lit, but a very funny concept. Good job!

(252 days ago)


Coloring Trouble at EB, inc.
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The light source on the mountains does not correspond with the light glow around the profile. The focus is too sharp, and the saturation has the top part of the mountain blue and transparent looking by the nose. The background lighting is coming from behind his head. The helmet is very blurry and bad in the front, with the semi-transparent bit right above the sunglasses needing to be cleaned up. The helmet also needs a more consistent lighting, since there is a bright light shining on the glasses, but the lighter part of the helmet is the fuzzy front. Good conept, but the execution needs help.

(254 days ago)


Climbing Everest
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The background in the photo should match the "cutout" effect of the profile, or the profile should be more realistic to match the background.

(254 days ago)


frame my profile
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The light on the statue is much dimmer than that on the welder.

(255 days ago)


dangerous work_47e30799d1dbf
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The dog's ear is too fuzzy, and the type does not blend, but the concept and overall exectuion are very good. Nice chop on the animals.

(263 days ago)


A Small World
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The cat image is too blurry with a "ghosting" edge above the cat and couch. The cat is looking up, not at the dog, and the dog image dips on the lower RH corner.

(280 days ago)


reflection
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster While there could be a bit more value shading to the dress to provide a more realistic tailoring to the construction, it is still a very well done piece, for the careful and meticulous creation of the dress. We all strive for perfection, and if that one detail is all that keeps this work from being perfect, I think you've accomplished quite a bit! Anyone who's ever painted a velvet dress will tell you that the light refraction can give it an odd depth under any but the brightest of light sources, so to me, the flatness is not so much of an issue.

(1 year and 35 days ago)


Fairy Girl
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The shade of green doesn't blend "naturally" with the bg image. The leaves are a bit too blue. Or the background is a bit too yellow...Really nice Rousseau-type effect.

(1 year and 35 days ago)


I love Rousseau
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Excellent effect on the fence. Very beautiful work on the dress, especially that bodice! Very well done.

(1 year and 35 days ago)


Fairy Girl
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Cute play on words, good chop, especially the ear texture!

(1 year and 36 days ago)


Eleafant
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster That is one GIANT snake. Good job, but there are no shadows at the base of the holder.

(1 year and 36 days ago)


Misplaced Lifebelt.
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster A bit hard to read.

(1 year and 36 days ago)


Animal Replacement
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Excellent chop! I had to look at it for a few seconds to figure out the changes. Creative and clean.

(1 year and 37 days ago)


Guitar
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Could have used some yellow pistils and stamens in the center, and it's a bit too dark, but a very nice concept!

(1 year and 37 days ago)


Flowers
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Excellent technical exectution in this piece. Good job!

(1 year and 37 days ago)


Pumpkin Love
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster What a delightful and fun concept. Keeps us looking at your entry! Excellent work (only found 9 so far...)

(1 year and 37 days ago)


Find 10 Things
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Maybe a beer mug instead of a bottle, positioned to look like a 'D'...

(1 year and 37 days ago)


Darts
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Some sort of label on the can would help, too.

(1 year and 37 days ago)


at the begining was the tuna
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Great content, but the colors (especially the pink) are too oversaturated. The bear looks almost peach colored...

(1 year and 37 days ago)


The Polar Bear
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The filter usage is a bit too obvious, her skin looks "sooty." Using the halftone filter would have given it a more "comic book" effect.

(1 year and 37 days ago)


Atomic Cheerleader
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Excellent effort, lots of different techniques, good composition and design. Well done!

(1 year and 37 days ago)


PST the Comic Book
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Wonderful rendering, great superhero! I hope he battles low-res enlargements next!

(1 year and 37 days ago)


COMIC BOOK HERO
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The contrast of the body is too high and overexposed for the rest of the image.

(1 year and 37 days ago)


Brunette represent
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster Nice work!

(1 year and 37 days ago)


Nanobots
Madster [lvl 5] [vp 52] [vote medals 2]:
avatar Madster The floor is illuminated, but the ceiling is dark...Where is the light source???

(1 year and 37 days ago)


Mega File